Kuala Lumpur: Polygraphs are used by law enforcement agencies, the judicial system, the private sector and the media in some countries to determine if a person is telling the truth.
A polygraph test should be made a prerequisite for such posts so that potential employers could assess the candidates to see if they were fit to deal with huge sums of money, national secrets, matters of national security or even sexual harassment or violent, infidelity,corruption and other offences that could not be corroborated with physical evidence.
Polygraphs measure physiological changes from three systems in people’s blood pressure, respiration and electro dermal response (palmar sweating or galvanic skin response in some form since 2016.
The polygraph test involved three stages: the pre-testing stage, testing stage and post-testing stage.
The pre-testing stage is when the subject is interviewed on his background, followed by the construction of questions. Depending on the issue or case, this stage takes about one to two hours.
The testing stage is when the subject sits on a special chair and answers “Yes” or “No” to questions. This involves three examinations consisting of at least 10 questions.
During the post-testing stage, there will be a diagnostic analysis and interrogation. There are numerous examples where the polygraph has led to a breakthrough or a confession.
But the whole three stages take a few hours, depending on the skill of examiners and the complexity of the cases.
The polygraph instrument produces only graphs. The examiners determine whether the person is deceptive or truthful. The qualified examiners are the “lie detectors” and truth verifiers and not the polygraph instrument.
The lying will produce physiological changes that polygraph examiner will be able to interpret these signs accurately and differentiate between the patterns of the graphs in an honest examinee’s nervousness from deception. He is capable to determine when an examinee engages in behaviours to distort the polygraph tracing and influence the test results.
However, to ensure and maintain integrity, the tests have to be conducted randomly. It is a preventive measure as employees will think twice before committing an offence, knowing that they could, at any time, be made to sit for the test. This is the beauty of the polygraph tests.
The American Polygraph Association(APA)has conducted over 250 studies which showed the reliability and accuracy of the polygraph is high. It is 98 percent accurate under good hands, using right questions, validated techniques, special room and chair, empirically based manual scoring and examined by certified polygraph examiners.
In Singapore, the police, the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau, the Ministry of Manpower, the Prisons Department, Customs, the Central Narcotics Bureau, Security and Intelligence agencies, and the military use it for personnel screening and investigations.
The Singapore prosecutor’s office also uses it in decision making whether or not to file charges while in Taiwan, a judge would subject an accused to a polygraph test prior to sentencing.
Agencies like the CIA, FBI, National Security Agency, US Secret Service, and the US Department of Defence, and the majority of US police departments use polygraph tests in recruitments and investigations or to determine links with terrorist activities.
In England and Wales, polygraph tests are used by the police in the monitoring of released sex offenders.
A few years ago, the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission(MACC) chief commissioner Azam Baki said the Public Service Commission (PSC) should consider making polygraph tests part of its recruitment policy, applying for posts within the management and professional groups, as these would comprise individuals who would be filling critical positions in public agencies.
He said only then could the service arrest the problem of corruption plaguing the sector and if the tests were reintroduced, it would augur well for the integrity of the sector as those with corrupt tendencies would be red-flagged from the start.
The former Director-General of the National Centre for Governance, Integrity, and Anti-Corruption, Tan Sri Abu Kassim Mohamed, stressed that the polygraph test can be used as evidence in a court case when administered by qualified examiners, but it is up to the judiciary to determine it.
President of the Shariah Lawyers Association, Musa Awang, said that based on existing law, the polygraph tests may be used as evidence in court but ultimately it is the judge who has the right to accept it or not.
As a result, the Chief Justice TunTengku Maimun Tuan stated that the judiciary is studying a proposal to use the results of polygraph tests as evidence in court but would involve amendments of Evidence Act 1950.
Currently, there is no precedent on the admissibility of polygraph evidence in Malaysia and Singapore except Malaysian’s civil court accepted polygraph as part of evidence in an insurance fraud case. The MACC, police, army and some companies are using polygraph for screenings and investigations.
If you ask how reliable and trustworthy a polygraph is — the answer: it is better than nothing.
Datuk Seri Akhbar Satar holds the professorial chair and director at Institute of Crime and Criminology(ICC), HELP University and a polygraph examiner.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Akhbar Satar
Mon Feb 06 2023
Currently, there is no precedent on the admissibility of polygraph evidence in Malaysia and Singapore except Malaysians civil court accepted polygraph as part of evidence in an insurance fraud case, said Datuk Seri Akhbar Satar - Astro AWANI
Prosedur graf kulit Faisal Halim tunjuk reaksi positif
Prosedur graf kulit atau tampalan kulit untuk menutup luka lecur tahap empat dialami pemain sayap sensasi Harimau Malaya dan Selangor FC Mohamad Faisal Abdul Halim yang cedera disimbah asid baru-baru
Sidang DUN Johor tergendala, Speaker minta tingkat keselamatan
Speaker Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Johor, Datuk Mohd Puad Zarkashi meminta supaya kawalan keselamatan ketika sidang DUN yang berlangsung di Bangunan Sultan Ismail dipertingkatkan.
Syarikat penerbangan boleh mulakan operasi antarabangsa di LTSIP
Kementerian Pengangkutan Mengalu-alukan syarikat penerbangan untuk mengendalikan operasi penerbangan antarabangsa di Lapangan Terbang Sultan Ismail Petra (LTSIP) Pengkalan Chepa, Kelantan.
AWANI Ringkas: Imigresen, KDN kaji guna QR di pintu masuk negara
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Lelaki hilang ketika berkelah ditemui lemas di Lata Bayu
Seorang lelaki yang dilaporkan hilang ketika berkelah bersama tiga rakannya di Lata Bayu, Asam Jawa, di sini ditemukan lemas.
Pemulihan pembuatan kekal utuh walaupun pertumbuhan IPP Malaysia perlahan pada Mac
Walaupun Indeks Pengeluaran Perindustrian (IPP) Malaysia perlahan iaitu 2.4 peratus pada Mac berbanding 3.1 peratus pada Februari, ia melepasi jangkaan dengan pemulihan dalam pembuatan kekal utuh.
Korban banjir kilat, gelongsoran lumpur di Sumatera Barat meningkat kepada 37
Daerah Agam paling teruk terjejas dengan 19 kematian, diikuti Daerah Tanah Datar (sembilan), Padang Pariaman (tujuh) dan Daerah Padang Panjang (dua).
Kuwait umumkan Kabinet baharu
Dekri Amir Kuwait dikeluarkan pada petang Ahad, mengumumkan pembentukan kabinet baharu yang diketuai oleh Perdana Menteri yang dilantik, Sheikh Ahmad Abdullah Al-Ahmad Al-Sabah.
[TERKINI] Pembangunan kasino di Forest City adalah fitnah - Onn Hafiz
Menteri Besar Johor, Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi sekali lagi menegaskan dakwaan Forest City diberi kelulusan untuk pembangunan kasino adalah fitnah liar dan tidak benar.
Bas dari Thailand dibenar masuk Malaysia, perlu permit APAD - Anthony Loke
Bas dari Thailand dibenarkan masuk ke Malaysia tetapi perlu membuat permohonan dengan Agensi Pengakutan Awam Darat (APAD) terlebih dahulu dan permit sementara akan dikeluarkan kepada pemohon tersebut.
[KOLUMNIS] SPRM dan kes berprofil tinggi: Ke mana sudahnya?
Amalan tadbir urus yang baik demi kepentingan awam adalah lebih penting daripada jawatan yang dipegang. Namun, bila agaknya ahli politik di negara ini boleh mengikut prinsip sedemikian rupa?
PRN: Pemimpin politik perlu bersikap 'gentleman', tidak rasuah pengundi - Akhbar Satar
Pemimpin politik yang akan bertanding dalam Pilihan Raya Negeri (PRN) di enam negeri tidak lama lagi diingatkan agar tidak menggunakan duit demi mendapatkan undi rakyat.
Belanjawan 2023: Pembatalan rundingan terus, jimat kos, lebih telus - Akhbar Satar
Inisiatif membatalkan kaedah rundingan terus bagi projek mega dalam Belanjawan 2023 mampu menjimatkan kos dan mengelakkan pemberian komisen kepada 'orang tengah'.
Indeks CPI: Skor negara menurun dipengaruhi pelbagai faktor penilaian - Akhbar Satar
Indikator dalam menentukan indeks persepsi rasuah bukan sahaja dipengaruhi oleh jumlah kes rasuah yang berlaku di dalam negara, namun ia membabitkan beberapa faktor termasuk sosio-ekonomi dan politik.
Apabila sedekah menjadi rasuah
Rasuah adalah ibu segala kegiatan jenayah dan kejahatan.
Sistem dalam negara perlu dipegang pemimpin berintegriti - Akhbar Satar
Ciri-ciri tersebut amat penting bagi memastikan penguatkuasaan sesuatu akta itu dapat dilaksanakan dengan telus.
PRU15: 'Ada udang di sebalik batu' apabila ahli politik enggan isytihar harta - Akhbar Satar
Ahli politik tidak perlu takut untuk dedahkan kekayaan jika ia datang dari sumber yang tidak melanggar undang-undang.
Rasuah: Hukuman pesalah golongan elit perlu lebih berat - Akhbar Satar
Golongan elit mempunyai wang yang cukup untuk mengupah peguam-peguam yang handal bagi membela mereka dalam penghakiman dan secara tidak langsung membebaskan mereka daripada pertuduhan tersebut.
PDRM terus perkasa integriti
Integriti sukar diajar. Ia terpahat dalam jiwa sama ada dimiliki seseorang atau tidak. Ada berpendapat doktrin agama juga tidak berupaya mengubah perasuah.
Revolusi senyap berlaku sejak banjir
Perkara ini berlaku kerana usaha-usaha membantu menyelesaikan masalah yang dihadapi rakyat lebih mudah diselesaikan dengan gerak kerja masyarakat tanpa melibat kerenah birokrasi.